Home > The Events > Update on Ban: Your Coffee Beer is Safe

Update on Ban: Your Coffee Beer is Safe

Its safe.

***This was originally posted on BreweryLaw.com.***

Earlier today, the Washington State Liquor Control Board imposed a ban on certain alcoholic beverages that contain caffeine, guarana, taurine, or other similar substances. The language of the ban regulation can be found on the LCB’s website. The ban is a direct response to a number of dangerous alcohol-related scares to college students who had been consuming Four Loko, an alcoholic energy drink.

I originally reported that the ban seemed to broad enough to include a prohibition on coffee beers – but it appears that is not the LCB’s intention. Breathe easy, beer lovers.

This law is being implemented under the State’s emergency powers, which provide for expedited regulatory powers in times of need. The law is temporary and will expire in March 2011. Thus, the LCB will be prompted to begin the regular law-making procedure to put together a final, more clear, regulation.

Here is the current language that is being put in place:

 

WAC 314-20-022 Alcohol energy drinks. No product that combines beer, strong beer, or malt liquor with caffeine, guarana, taurine, or other similar substances which are commonly referred to as “alcohol energy drinks” may be imported into the state, produced, manufactured, distributed, sold or offered for sale by a licensed retailer in the state of Washington after November 17, 2010.

 

Many will say that the language is a bit broad, referring to products that “combine beer….with caffeine…which are commonly referred to as ‘alcohol energy drinks’.” First of all many products, including coffee, contain caffeine. Secondly, “alcohol energy drinks’ is an undefined term that could bear a myriad of meanings.

Its difficult to enact a regulation that specifically applies to a particular product. Remember, the LCB doesn’t simply want Four Loko to stop referring to itself as an “energy drink” in order to avoid the law. So, the LCB will have to use discretion in how this law is enforced until a more clear final regulation is put in place.

The LCB will rely on the purpose of this law in determining its enforcement. The purpose was to prevent that production and sale of “energy drinks” that are pre-mixed with alcohol. In fact, the LCB’s fact sheet specifically states that the ban does not implicate the mixing of liquor and energy drinks (i.e. Red Bull & Vodka), stating that “the ban applies only to pre-mixed, malt-based products.”

Coffee beers are pre-mixed beverages containing added caffeine. So, they fall along the lines of this regulation. Alas, the LCB does not intend to go after them, as they are not commonly referred to as “alcohol energy drinks.” It requires a bit of interpretation, but it will work for most in the beer industry.

The LCB informed me that coffee beers will not be implicated because brewers add coffee, not caffeine, and for the sole purpose of flavor. The difference is that Four Loko, and beverages like it, add caffeine, and for the sole purpose of “energy.”

A little interpretation in enforcement should keep this from immediately affecting the brewing industry. However, a more advanced law-crafting procedure looms and the State could decide to include coffee beer. In 2009, the FDA decided to make a run at pulling these beers off the market.

The combination of recent alcohol poisoning and the difficulty of regulating a small sample of a particular type of product (“energy” drinks v. caffeine-added drinks) might require the LCB to enact a more sweeping regulation. Thus, it may behoove the Washington Brewers Guild and other brewing groups to get involved in the new rule-making procedure.

For now, Mocha Death is safe.

 

About these ads
  1. Heather McClung
    November 10, 2010 at 3:23 pm

    Although the implementation of this emergency ruling was a surprise, the Brewers Guild has been aware of this issue for quite some time and has been proactive in protecting brewers’ interests for the last year. Months ago, we had verbal confirmation from the LCB chairperson stating it is not their intent to hurt the craft beer industry and they will work with the Guild to craft language to ensure that we retain our brewing freedom.
    It is up to all of us to make sure they stay that way. When the rule is up for public comment in a few days, be sure to submit your comments!

    • November 10, 2010 at 9:13 pm

      Thanks Heather. I was very happy to learn that you guys were involved with this regulation. We hope that beer lovers will get involved in the public comment process and let the LCB know that microbrews using caffeine-containing flavorings are a whole different story.

      I can’t live without my coffee stout!

  1. November 10, 2010 at 3:10 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.